Republican Refers to Transgender Member as a Man, Cutting Short a House Hearing trendy New year 2025

 Republican Refers to Transgender Member as a Man, Cutting Short a House Hearing

 Skip to Content Skip to Site Index, Section Navigation, and Search For $25 per week, subscribe. Trump

 Administration

 

  

 Major Changes Disappearing Words

 subsequently rehired Tracking of Suits Is That Legal?

 You now have access; you can continue reading with your keyboard. A Republican cuts short a House hearing by referring to a transgender member as a man. Texas Representative Keith Self insisted on calling Representative Sarah McBride, the first member of Congress who came out as transgender, "Mr. McBride" and, when questioned about it, called a halt to the meeting. Share the entire article. Would you like us to open comments on this article?

 We don’t open everything, but our moderators consider reader requests.

 Find out more Log in to make a request Come back. What Readers are Discussing Right Now

 House G.O.P. dares the Senate to accept its bill to prevent a shutdown. 120| Chris commented Huhu ago

 House G.O.P. dares the Senate to accept its bill to prevent a shutdown. Democrat from New Hampshire Senator Jeanne Shaheen will not run for office again in 2026. 18| Eric S made a comment 2 hours ago Democrat from New Hampshire Senator Jeanne Shaheen will not run for office again in 2026. The Latest Experiment by Lady Gaga? Happiness.

 163| a person commented 3 hours ago The Latest Experiment by Lady Gaga? Happiness.

 I'm being punished by my mother for not coming out to her sooner. Help!

 24| Anonymous commented 2 hours ago I'm being punished by my mother for not coming out to her sooner. Help!

 

 TRANSCRIPT

 Republican confronted over transgender Democrat misgendering The ranking Democrat on the subcommittee spoke out in support of Delaware Representative Sarah McBride after the Republican legislator misidentified her gender. "I now recognize the Delaware representative, Mr. McBride.” “I'm grateful, Madam Chair. Ranking member Keating, also wonderful —” “Mr. Chairman, could you repeat your introduction again, please?” “Yes, it is a standard that we have established on the House floor, and I am simply —” "What is that standard, Mr. Chairman? Would you please repeat what you just said when you introduced a duly elected American representative? “I will. The representative from Delaware, Mr. McBride.” “Mr. Chairman, you have broken the rules. Mr. Chairman, have you no decency? Even though I have some acquaintance with you, this is not acceptable. "We'll keep going with this." “You will not continue it with me unless you introduce a duly elected representative the right way.” "This hearing has been postponed." from Delaware, Mr. McBride.”

 The ranking Democrat on the subcommittee spoke out in support of Delaware Representative Sarah McBride after the Republican legislator misidentified her gender. Credit... Haiyun Jiang for The New York Times; Kenny Holston/The New York Times

 Karni, Annie By Annie Karni

 Reporting from the Capitol

 

 A Republican lawmaker abruptly adjourned a congressional hearing on Tuesday after being challenged for referring to Representative Sarah McBride, Democrat of Delaware and the first openly transgender lawmaker in Congress, as a man.

 When Representative Keith Self of Texas introduced his colleague by calling her "Mr. McBride.”

 Ms. McBride, who entered Congress knowing she would present a unique target for Republicans who have politicized and attacked transgender people, has generally chosen to let such moments slide. She briefly expressed her displeasure on Tuesday by returning Mr. Self's insult, to which she responded, "Thank you, Madam Chair," before continuing her remarks. Show the entire article ADVERTISEMENT

 Avoid advertising ADVERTISEMENT

 Avoid advertising You can access all of The Times at any time. Site Index

 Site Information Navigation

  in the year 2025, The New York Times Company 

A chronicle of discord and division: Republican refers to transgender member as a man and cuts short House hearing: Once thought of as safe havens for reasoned debate, the hallowed halls of legislative discourse are increasingly becoming battlegrounds for culture wars, where identity and ideology clash with visceral ferocity. A recent incident in a state House hearing in which a Republican legislator repeatedly referred to a transgender Democratic colleague as a man, which resulted in the abrupt end of the meeting, is a clear example of this growing polarization. Rather than being merely a hiccup in the procedure, this event highlights the deep divisions that exist regarding transgender rights and the difficulties that legislative bodies that are tasked with navigating these complex issues face. The actual incident took place in the midst of a larger discussion regarding proposed legislation regarding transgender individuals' access to healthcare and protections against discrimination. The precise details of the proposed bills, while crucial, often become secondary to the incendiary rhetoric and personal attacks that dominate the discourse. The contentious exchange in this particular hearing took place during the time allotted for member comments, a stage where lawmakers typically share their perspectives and engage in conversation. Witness accounts and subsequent media reports claim that the Republican lawmaker intentionally and consistently used the transgender Democratic member's former name and male pronouns during his allotted time. Immediately, Democratic lawmakers and advocacy groups who were present at the hearing expressed outrage at this act, which they perceived as a flagrant attempt to deny the member's gender identity. The transgender member, clearly upset, tried to address the frequent misgendering, but the Republican legislator insisted once more. The core issue at stake, beyond the immediate procedural breakdown, lies in the fundamental question of respect and recognition. Misgendering, the act of referring to a transgender person using a gender pronoun or name that does not align with their gender identity, is widely recognized as a form of discrimination and a denial of their lived experience. It has the potential to cause a significant amount of emotional harm and contribute to feelings of being excluded and invisible. For transgender individuals, the affirmation of their gender identity is not merely a matter of personal preference but a crucial aspect of their well-being and sense of self. Being consistently misgendered can be deeply invalidating and traumatizing, especially in a public and official setting like a legislative hearing. It conveys that their colleagues and, by extension, the institution they represent do not recognize or respect their identity. The Republican lawmaker's actions were not simply a matter of linguistic disagreement but a deliberate attempt to undermine the legitimacy and dignity of the transgender member. By refusing to acknowledge their gender identity, he effectively sought to erase their presence and deny their right to participate fully in the legislative process. A form of power play, this act of erasure aims to establish dominance and strengthen existing hierarchies. The immediate aftermath of the incident was characterized by a flurry of condemnations and calls for accountability. Democratic lawmakers and advocacy groups denounced the Republican lawmaker's behavior as transphobic and unacceptable, demanding an apology and disciplinary action. They emphasized the need for legislative bodies to create a safe and inclusive environment for all members, regardless of their gender identity.

 Republican leaders, on the other hand, faced a delicate balancing act. While some individuals privately expressed disapproval of the legislator's actions, others publicly defended the legislator's right to voice his opinions, citing religious liberty and freedom of speech. This reluctance to unequivocally condemn the misgendering reflects the deep divisions within the Republican Party on issues related to transgender rights.

 The incident also reignited debates about the role of language in shaping social perceptions and reinforcing power dynamics. Language is a powerful tool for constructing and maintaining social realities, not a neutral instrument. In addition to being a matter of semantics, the deliberate use of misgendering language is a form of symbolic violence that serves to deny the reality of transgender identities and perpetuate harmful stereotypes. The clash over language in this context is inextricably linked to broader debates about gender identity and the definition of womanhood and manhood. For many conservatives, the concept of gender is rooted in biological sex, the physical characteristics assigned at birth. They view transgender identities as a rejection of this biological reality and a challenge to traditional gender roles.

 For transgender individuals and their allies, however, gender is understood as a social construct, a complex interplay of identity, expression, and roles that may not align with biological sex. They argue that the right to self-identify is a fundamental human right and that discrimination occurs when this right is denied. The incident in the state House hearing also highlighted the challenges facing legislative bodies in addressing issues related to transgender rights. For dealing with instances of misgendering or other forms of discrimination against transgender members, many legislatures lack clear policies and procedures. This lack of clarity can create a climate of uncertainty and vulnerability for transgender lawmakers and their allies.

 Furthermore, the incident underscored the need for greater education and awareness about transgender issues among lawmakers and the public. A lack of exposure and comprehension frequently leads to misperceptions and prejudices about transgender people. A concerted effort to promote education, dialogue, empathy, and respect is needed to address these misconceptions. This incident has far-reaching consequences that go beyond the immediate setting of the state House hearing. It demonstrates the weaponization of identity in political discourse and a growing trend toward political polarization. The culture wars, once confined to the fringes of society, have now infiltrated the mainstream, shaping legislative debates and policy decisions.

 The incident serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of dehumanizing language and the erosion of civility in political discourse. When lawmakers resort to personal attacks and deliberate misgendering, they undermine the integrity of the legislative process and erode public trust in government institutions.

 Moving forward, it is imperative that legislative bodies take concrete steps to address the challenges highlighted by this incident. This includes enacting clear policies and procedures for handling instances of misgendering and other forms of discrimination against transgender members. It also requires investing in education and training programs to promote awareness and understanding of transgender issues among lawmakers and staff.

 In addition, it is essential to cultivate a climate of respect and inclusion in legislative chambers, where all members, regardless of gender identity, feel safe and valued. This necessitates a dedication to civility and an eagerness to engage in respectful dialogue, even regarding contentious topics. The incident in the state House hearing serves as a stark reminder of the ongoing struggle for transgender rights and the challenges facing legislative bodies in navigating these complex issues. It emphasizes the need for increased education, awareness, and respect, in addition to a commitment to creating a welcoming and secure environment for all members. In a society that purports to value equality and justice, the denial of transgender identities is a profound contradiction. The struggle for transgender rights is a struggle for our democracy's soul as well as a matter of individual dignity. It measures our capacity to create a society that is more just and compassionate as well as our dedication to equality and inclusion principles.